Review 4 of 39
Price Paid:
$700.00
from samys Summary: Interesting how far apart the opinions are for this lens. I'm wondering if Tamron improved it in recent years as recent reviews seem much more positive.
I have had this lens for about a week and use it on a Canon 10. It is the only NON- CANON "L" lens that I own, so I am veery critical when it comes to performance. I conducted a series of tests at various focal lengths and apertures, comparing this to the Canon 28-70L (one of Canon's best) and felt the Tamron performance was outstanding in head to head results! I printed 8x10s on a Canon 9100 of enlarged sections of the images and could see no differences in the results. OK....its possible with optical testing equipment the Canon lens might test better: I'm not equipped with such equipment. But after 50 years of photographic experience, I am certainly capable of comparing prints for resolution and contrast and saturation, and thats what matters! This lens does not disappoint! But just to be sure, I showed the prints to my photo pro buddies who thought the Tamron results were equal to or better than the Canon.
I think the construction is very solid and I like the "drag" adjustment feature on the zoom ring. I am diasappointed that there is no manual focus capability while in the auto focus mode.
This is a heavy lens, but if you own any of the Canon "L" zooms, this should pose no problems. The filters are only a few more bucks than the 77mm required by several of my Canon lenses...not a big deal.
I have not shot in direct sunlight, so I can't comment on flare characteristics, but I haven't shot with a lens YET that didn't have a problem in those conditions.
Bottom line, I think this a great performer with a nice range for landscapes and portrait work with a fixed f/2.8 for low light shooting...recommended! Strengths: Excellent image quality
Very practical, and usable zoom range
Solid consruction
Fast, fixed aperture
Adjustable "drag" setting for zooming Weaknesses: Don't buy if weight is an issue Similar Products Used: Canon 28-70L
Canon 70-200 f/4L
Canon 17-35L
Canon 28-135 IS (no longer own)
Canon 28-105 (no longer own)
|