Review 4 of 7
Price Paid:
$2900.00
from Jim Kuehl Summary: OK, I admit it, the new body with the new finder while great is expensive, but you don't have to go that route. Buy any of the SWC/M models with T* (mine is the CF version, but only because I couldn't find a used Compur version) for under $3,000 and trust me you will get used to the external bubble-level.
What you will not get used to is the extraordinary results. Color, B&W, 50 or 3200 ISO, shot from the hip or from the tripod, whatever you do (maybe not standard portrait - I'll give you that) the results will have you lifting your jaw off the floor. The sharpness is just breathtaking, and that nice large negative or transparency (use Velvia and the world will never have looked so good) will have you ordering 16x16 custom enlargements.
Now if I haven't quite convinced you and you are a B&W photographer, you can get a good non-T* outfit for well under $2,000. Many people, even some dealers will tell you that while there is a difference between T* and non-T* it is a difference without consequence. But you know if you are a color user you will always have that nagging doubt in the back of your mind, so spend the extra bucks and sleep easy at night.
A friend of mine is a serious amateur who recently purchased the Contax 645 auto-focus, a bunch of lenses, backs, etc. for around $10,000. After looking at my Velvia transparencies, she is rethinking her decision. She wanted auto-focus, but may now be willing to live without it. She wanted interchangable lenses, but is now willing to live without them. She wanted fancy metering and TTL flash, she is now willing to live without them. She wanted reflex viewing, she... well you get the idea.
Yes this is a camera which makes you think, but you know what, when you think you take better pictures. Gil Ghitelman (a great dealer, although I did not purchase this camera from him) once remarked to me that just like a Rollie TLR a person always regrets selling a SWC. Buy it, use it, you will have no regrets.
Now one final word about the bubble-level. The ergonomics of the new finder are clearly better, try both and compare for yourself. However, part of the beauty of the SWC, in all of its incarnations (see www.gilghitelman.com for a nice history) is the classic quality of its design - just like the Leica. The megaphone finder of the older version is simply more beautiful and quite possibly more durable - metal not plastic.
So, if you want fine photography without a lot of battery-powered automation getting in the way, get the SWC - no regrets. Strengths: Simply superb. Compact medium format with the finest ultra wide-angle lens. No distortion, no vignetting, no fuss, no bother. After a while even using the bubble-level becomes natural. Weaknesses: My Leica rangefinders (10 bodies M1-M6, 22 lenses including 3 21mm's) are just gathering dust - who would have thought. Similar Products Used: Leicas with 21mm Super-Angulons and Aspheric. Customer Service: Sticky shutter release but fixed easily and cheaply by Professional Camera Repair in NYC. The real beauty of this camera is that there is so little to go wrong.
|