Review 4 of 11
Price Paid:
$0.00 Summary: This camera is junk. Technically speaking, it works as advertised. The results are just terrible. I tested this camera side by side with the other 3 Samurai half-frame cameras that I own, as well as a Profile 4000 IX demo from the dealer, and the quality of the results from both of these cameras is so obviously inadequate.
The half-frame negative is slightly smaller that the APS negative, but exposed in a good camera, the results are far superior to APS. Plus I get 72 exposures on a roll.
For processing, I used Kodak for both 35mm and APS. Thank goodness Kodak still processes the half-frame format. All the Kodak hype about their Advantix film is just so much hot air. I''m completely at a loss to understand why they are pushing this crummy film on one hand, and no longer producing their outstanding Kodachrome 25 on the other hand.
I used Kodak APS film (Advantix) in 100, 200 and 400 speeds and Kodak Gold 35mm film in 100 and 200 and Max in 400 for my test. Shooting the same subjects side by side, the results are incredibly different. My biggest complaints are with the grain and color saturation in all three Advantix films and the lousy focus with the Profile camera. I was really amazed that the Advantix film seemed to over-saturate the colors, particularly reds and blues. The Samurai X3.0, X4.0 and Z models were all right on in focus and exposure. If I didn''t know which film was exposed in each of these cameras, I would not have been able to distinguish which photo came from which camera. Too bad Yashica quit making the Samurai series. They quit making a winner to produce junk. Strengths: The physical design of the camera makes it quite easy to use, just like the earlier Samurai cameras. It will complete my collection of Samurai cameras. I can point to it and explain to my students how technology doesn''t necessarily make things better over time. Weaknesses: Specifically the APS format (inclusive of Kodak''s Advantix film, very poor focus and exposure control. Similar Products Used: Yashica Samurai X3.0, X4.0, Z and ZL. I have not used any other APS camera -- and most definitely will not. Customer Service: I am considering sending this camera to Yashica to see if there is some mechanical defect, but since my test involved using two of these cameras with the same poor results, I''m not sure.
|