Review 3 of 3
Price Paid:
$450.00
from company site Summary: Decent software makes this scanner a breeze to use. No one would suggest you get state-of-the art scans, compared with professional drum scanning or the best 35-dedicated film scanners. However, it isn't how far short it comes from a dedicated 35mm dedicated scanner, but how close it comes. You can set it to output an unmanipulated high-bit, high res scan, which you can tweak in Photoshop, then save as 8-bit. It's great for checking out a roll of 35mm or medium format. Just load the whole roll in the film holder and batch scan them all in one step. Check the results in Photoshop and throw out the dogs. Save money by doing away with in-store printing 4x5's of your medium format.
I think it's unrealistic to expect perfect scans straight out of any scanner. Some tonal and/or color tweaking is going to be necessary. Sharpening in Unsharp Mask will be necessary. With Kodachromes and silver-based black-and-white, you will have to go after dust specs and scratches in an imaging software.
The V700 makes the process about as pain free as any I've seen.
You can use Ed Hamrick's scanning software or full-blown Silverfast to wring detail out of shadows in slides, but both have learning curves fron hell. Epson's scanning software will handle most situations. If you're very picky about your results, or make your living in photography, put out the bucks for the best 35mm or medium format dedicated scanner. Strengths: simplicity of operation
reliability
Set correctly in Professional Mode, it returns a good scan, like a camera RAW, in high bit, ready to edit in Photoshop or Elements. Weaknesses: Dust clean-up too destructive to off-the-film images. Use Digital Ice light. Maybe this feature is designed for scanning damaged prints.
Automatic cropping often mis-crops. Use manual cropping.
Grain reduction useful only if you have a severe grain problem
Do sharpening in Photoshop; not enough control in Epson Scan.
Lame instructions. The company supplies film holder height adjusters but there's no clue in the instructions as to what they are for. or how to use them.
Similar Products Used: HP S20 film scanner, the worst of the lot.
Nikon LS 2000- wonderful scanner until the dirt insider shut it down.
Canon 4000US - still going strong. Customer Service: Not the best, but at least they answer the phone.
Rep had no answer for conflict with SCSI scanner on the same computer keeping Twain interface from working with the Epson. The solution was to have the Epson scan to a file, instead of directly into Photoshop. Sure another user has experienced this.
|