Review 2 of 3
Price Paid:
$100.00
from Second Hand Summary: This review is based on the use of Nikon F80/N80 and Nikon 2.8/300 AF lens, using Fuji slide film and a tripod.
According to the encouraging results of the shorter Kenko converters with this particular setup, I went lunatic and procured the 3x converter to get up to 900mm effective focal length. I did not expect much more than that it would work somehow and deliver something like an image.
If you read carefully what the instruction leaflet sais, this TC is designed to be used with tele lenses of f/2.8 or brighter (maybe tailored for the Tokina 2.8/300 lens). It is certainly not designed to boost a zoom lens.
To make the story short, it works and delivers images. Period. Nobody shall expect particular image quality, but my results are reasonable with respect to the handling problems inevitable when shooting with extremely long focal length, i.e. a tripod is a "must".
I noticed acceptable sharpness but a distinguishable loss of contrast in the images. I recommend to under-expose by about 0.5 f-stop when using such a combination. I could not detect any quality improvement in stopping down the aperture, and the loss of light, equivalent to three f-stops, does not encourage to stop down at all. I also noticed some slight colour fringing towards the corners.
To my surprise, I found the handling was not more problematic that using a 2x converter. This item is considerably longer than a 2x TC, I expected more trouble with panning motions and mirror shake, but it is virtually just the same order of magnitude.
In my opinion, this TC produces a magnified cutout of the centre part of the prime lens image, because the otherwise noticeable light fall-off towards the corners is completely absent. With the a.m. combination I cannot notice any vignetting at fully open aperture.
This TC is a nice tool to occasionally boost a good prime lens to the limits, and I recommend it to all amateurs wishing to experience photography at this level. It is useful to elaborate skills in techniques of photography. It does probably not satisfy the needs of professional photographers.
My rating accounts for the fact that this is a unique tool and that limited optical quality should be expected. Strengths: Identical good build quality like other Kenko Pro300 converters.
No observable vignetting.
No change to coulour rendition.
Fits well and works with Nikon mechanical AF lenses.
Reasonable sharpness. Weaknesses: Visible reducion of contrast.
Requires careful exposure metering, as it appears to over-expose slightly.
Not good enough for people addicted to top quality. Similar Products Used: Other Kenko Pro300 series, Zeiss Mutar II Customer Service: Not needed for this item, otherwise excellent in Germany.
|