Nikon AF 28-105 f/3.5-4.5D Zoom Nikkor 35mm Zoom
Nikon AF 28-105 f/3.5-4.5D Zoom Nikkor 35mm Zoom
[Mar 04, 2001]
Sandy Rand
Expert
Strength:
Very good optical quality for the money. Also is light weight, which makes for a good touring lens!
Weakness:
Tends to have pincushion distortion at the lower focal lenghts, but for the money, I can overlook that! A great all-purpose lens which performs admirably in most situations. This is a truly ecomical all purpose lens that is a great alternative to the AF-S series when cost is a factor. Enlargements are great to 16x20 with Fuji Provia-F 100. You will not be disapointed!!! Customer Service Have never needed in 20 years of owning Nikon. Similar Products Used: Nikkor 17-35mm AF-S |
[Mar 02, 2001]
Mourits van Ballegooijen
Expert
Strength:
usefull zoom range,very good sharpness,contrast low distortion and ofcourse the macro cap.
Weakness:
Everything could be better, but it would be nice if it was F3.5 all through the zoom range.The hood is very large! A very usefull high quality zoom lens with very good optics and a very pleasing macro capability.Haven't seen any flare yet with the gigantic lens hood!The reviewer before me couldn't help himself from comparing it with a 50mm f1.8 and it didn't meet his demands and thus it got a undeserving low review.Nothing not even Nikkors AFS 28-70 can be compared with a good prime lens!Good primes like F50/1.8&F50/1.4 always beat zooms in term of sharpness,contrast and lack of distortion(actually 0%with these primes)!But then you don't have wide angle through tele range.So both choices are compromises;highest optical performance or a higher practicallity.when searching for high practicallity and very good optics for your Nikon F/N camera at a reasonable price then can't get around this lens! Customer Service Never used it,but heard good stories about it here in the Netherlands Similar Products Used: Nikkor af 35-105,tokina 28-105(very good lens for under $200,-)F-F5 etc. etc. |
[Mar 02, 2001]
Andreas Becker
Intermediate
Strength:
Very usefull zoom-range.
Weakness:
It is really not a pro-lens, cannot compare to prime lenses. I used the 28-105 on a journey in Egypt/Sinai and was rather disapointed with the results on Fuji-slide-film. Customer Service Never needed. Similar Products Used: Nikon 1,8/50 |
[Mar 29, 2001]
Gary Crooks
Expert
Strength:
Very good balance of weight, quality and price. Generally sharp stopped down 2 stops, but acceptable open to open+1 stop. Center is much better than edges. This seems to be a Nikon design point these days. Macro ok when subject is in center.
Weakness:
A little disapponted on the extreme ends wide open. But I had a 24-120mm and it was much softer in the center, but had almost as good of edges as the 28-105 at some focal lengths. Good zoom lens to have with macro as bonus. I try to stop down, if possible to offset zoom quality loss. Use primes for ultimate quality and speed. Considering the cost, this is a great lens. Only a little more than the 28-80 all plastic lens with no macro. Customer Service Never yet. Similar Products Used: most consumer Nikon lens including 24-120 and new 24-85, some 3rd party |
[Mar 29, 2001]
J Matson
Intermediate
Strength:
28-105mm zoom range.
Weakness:
Vignetting at 28mm 3.5 Wanted a general purpose zoom for my N80. For those like me, that cannot afford the Nikkor 28-70mm 2.8D ED-IF AF-S, overall the Nikkor 28-105 3.5-4.5 is one of better rated "consumer" general purpose lens that's currently available for Nikon camera users. (See www.photodo.com "MTF" Tests, www.photozone.de "Lens Test Guide" and Popular Photography Jul 2000 Page 29) Customer Service In 20 over years of using Nikon equipment had not used. Similar Products Used: Have used various Nikkor prime/zoom lenses. |
[Apr 27, 2001]
Jeff Kalmus
Professional
Strength:
Inexpensive
Weakness:
Auto focus a little weak The strengths of this lens more than outweigh it's weaknesses. The vignetting I expected with a polarizing filter and although the auto focus is nice to have I got much sharper results using it manually (seems to be the case with most Nikon zooms). Customer Service Never needed it Similar Products Used: Nikon 75-240 |
[May 03, 2001]
Romke van Dijk
Intermediate
Strength:
great travellens, top colors, fast enough af, did everything M till now.
Weakness:
availble light fotography, clusy macro switch I needed a sophisticated point and shoot Camera, less times kids etc., with a does it all lens. and I am quite happy together with my new second hand 8008s Similar Products Used: Any Canon Prime Fd you can think off, |
[May 16, 2001]
Elson Tan
Intermediate
Strength:
1) Price
Weakness:
1) Vignetting at wide A very good lens at a reasonable price. I bought it just 2 weeks ago, and have already taken 2 rolls with it, and I am very please with the outcome. Will be a good all purpose lens for trips and for anyone who just take up photography. Similar Products Used: None |
[May 22, 2001]
Pylinski Tomasz
Expert
Strength:
1. focusing well damped in MF
Weakness:
1. large front element not well protected by the barrel requiring protective filter which in turm may cause vigneting at wide setting. Appears to be a great bargain lens with wide range and more than good optical quality. Similar Products Used: 35-70 af nikkor |
[May 28, 2001]
Kelvin
Intermediate
Strength:
Very useful focal length range.
Weakness:
Large lens hood A good all-round lens that you can leave on the camera and use for most of your daily photography needs. Almost as sharp as primes. The macro feature is very useful. Images are sharper than the Nikon 24-120. The Sigma feels much more plasticky and I was unimpressed with the images it produced. The only wish is that this lens was a little faster although it is probably fast enough for most situations. The lens hood is a little too big! In summary, this is a great lens for the money. Customer Service None needed Similar Products Used: Sigma 28-105 |